Adrenal Fatigue

Losing Hope with Naturthroid, Venturing into Compounds and Canada

Posted by Miss Lizzy
December 2, 2010

Hi Friends!

It’s been ages since my last post. While I’ve been a totally bad blogger, to my credit I’ve collected lots of good info to share. The big news: I’ve been experimenting with desiccated thyroid medicine! After the Armour reformulation fiasco two years ago, and then the Naturthroid reformulation about six months ago I’ve gone renegade and decided I needed to find stable medicine.

I took the advice of many of the great ladies on the Stop the Thyroid Madness and the Yahoo Thyroid Group and decided to try having my medicine made by a compound pharmacy. Why go with a compound? Well, it’s all in the filler.  When Armour and Naturthroid reformulated, people claim the new cellulose filler was the root of all evil. I don’t really understand why but I definitely found my thyroid symptoms got worse after both reformulations. Whatever the drug companies did, it was Bad (and not in a Michael Jackson way). The lesson learned: no more cellulose for me.


A Journey into Compound Pharmacies

Thyroid medicine is my life line, it has to work, and I have to know it’s reliable. So that’s when I decided to venture out on my own into the mysterious world of compound pharmacies. For those of you who don’t know, compound pharmacies are super cool. Basically, they will custom make your medicine using the filler you want. Kind of like “Build-a-Bear” of the medicine world.

A visitor here on the site, Kama (Hi Kama!), recommended a great compound pharmacy called Colliers Drug in Arkansas. I got on the phone with Rodney at Colliers and he was fantastic (and has a super cute southernish accent!). See contact info below. I explained that I wanted a thyroid medicine that could dissolve under my tongue (rather than capsule form which has to be swallowed). Rodney offered to make my medicine in a form called a “Troche” (or lozenge). They even sweetened it to cover the awful desiccated thyroid smell. Also I explained I wanted Vitamin C or Acidophilus as a filler (suggested by STTM) instead of cellulose, which Rodney was totally happy to accommodate.  It’s a great little pill. I’m very proud.


Anyway, back to the important details. It’s been a month on the compound thyroid medicine and, so far, my hypothyroid symptoms seem to be improving. Most importantly to all us ladies, I am finally losing the 6-7 lbs I freakishly gained for no reason after the Naturthroid reformulation. Yay! Now you would think that I would feel better right away on the compound but it took about three weeks before my body decided to like the new medicine. So a big thumbs up for the effectiveness of Colliers thyroid compound!

That’s all the good stuff. Now, the downside…  the compound is waaaaaay more expensive than the Naturthroid prescription. It costs $50 for a one month supply with partial insurance coverage, zoinks! I know *sigh*. It’s a lot of money.

It’s unlikely I can afford to stay on the compound, but at least I know where to get reliable medicine. Instead I’ve decided to try another medicine called Erfa, out of Canada, which was highly recommended by the Yahoo Thyroid group. The ladies say Erfa is “like the old Armour” and it costs about $50 for a three month supply. Now, its worth noting that switching medicine too quickly can really upset my body. My plan is to stay on the compound for another month just to make sure it works well. And then try Erfa by adding it into the daily medicine mix slowly.

Once I have more info on Erfa I will share what I’ve learned. Meanwhile, if you want to try my compound give Colliers a call and ask for Rodney.





Rodney at Colliers is SO awesome. He gave us his direct phone extension for ordering the compound (479) 935-4336. Ask for the “Miss Lizzy Compound” and he will hook you up. (A doctor’s prescription is of course needed.)




  1. hh December 4, 2010 10:18 pm

    Hi Lizzy,Thank you so much for this post. I was diagnosed hypothyroid this June after 3 years of trying to convince a whole range of doctors something wasn't right. I am however still struggling with it. I've been on Naturethroid which has helped somewhat, but not enough (still have all of the classic symptoms like you.) Your post helps me make sense out of it. Thank you!!

  2. Lizzy December 7, 2010 6:15 pm

    Hi HH,I totally hear you! If you feel like something is not right with your body, you are so right to follow your instinct! It's not always something I can put my finger on, but I have this general sense when things just aren't quite right and that's my tip to keep exploring treatment.Like with the Naturthroid reformulation, mysteriously I gained 6-8 lbs and just couldn't lose the weight this summer (doing all the same stuff as before!). On the compound the weight came off in a month. Love that! And I generally feel happier and more stable emotionally.Keep up the great work and you will get there!xxooLizzy

  3. Sue Taylor December 28, 2010 6:58 pm

    Hi Lizzy, i just sent a lengthy post to another section of your website and then I found this!!Could this be my problem? I'm calling your boy today! No more screwing around! Thanks for using your great brain function to help us out! Sue

  4. Sue Taylor December 28, 2010 7:05 pm

    NOOOOOOO! Don't try ERFA! It sucks! Many women I have found that tried it were so sorry! For me it just stopped working! I have been very ill and ended up gluten intolerant to boot! YIPPEE! I have read that it seems ok for men but for some reason noit women and several women I've talked to refer to it as being ERFA'd !I'm sorry to rain on your parade, you could try it. But as soon as you feel "off" STOP! don't stick with it for a year like I did! you will pay a dear price. Dr. Lowe and I discussed this and he said he found the same thing. He feels I ended up gluten intolerant from low thyroid function for so long…from ERFA. Just a warning. Best, Sue

  5. Lizzy January 3, 2011 1:45 am

    Hi Sue,Just seeing your post now. WOW about ERFA! I am so glad you told me! Luckily, I decided to stay on the compound for a while so I didn't try ERFA yet. Okay, so there you have it. Watch out for Erfa! I hope my compound from Colliers works for others.xxooLizzy

  6. ladybug April 4, 2011 2:20 pm

    Hi Lizzy-Wanted to check in and see if you are still improving with the compound. I am almost out of my Naturthroid and am going to ask my doctor next time about Colliers. Are you still a fan!??!

  7. Lizzy April 5, 2011 7:13 pm

    Hi Ladybug,,I was just thinking I need to do an update! I have been happy with the compound from Collier's and continue to do well. But in the past month I have gained about 4 pounds and am not sure why. It could be that I have been eating a little more sugar but I ate lots of sugar at Christmas didn't gain weight. So I am not sure what the story is, except maybe its seasonal. I am watching the weight to see what happens. But all around yes the compound has been great for me!xxooLizzy

  8. Kristi May 18, 2011 3:06 pm

    Hi, I literally stumbled upon your blog and am so glad I did!! I am on Armour thyroid and having a horrible time. I actually just moved and had to switch doctors. For the compound did you have to have a perscription for the compound or can you just have a perscription for Armour or something and then have him compound you something? Thank you.Kristi

  9. April August 3, 2011 4:17 am

    Hi im April. I wanted to make a comment. I have been struggling with Hypothyroidism for about 10 yrs now. I took I131 in 2002. I was misdaignosed from a crazy Doc. So now I am paying the price for his aka dr mistake. I have tried all the thyroid meds on the market. Nothing works for me. So now I am getting to know the ppl at The Happy Hormone Cottage/ Dr Pelletier btw she totally rocks! She will go a farther step than any dr I have met. Trust me I have met some Dr's too. lol. It has taken me about 8 yrs of my life but I have found the right Dr. in my past I have met with Dr's in The Cleveland Clinic, WILSON'S Syndrome, in Michigan, even Keneith Blanchard Massachusetts. Plus phone consultsations across the U.S.. We are going to do Saliva Test, plus after many yrs of assuming I might have RT3, I am finally getting that checked! So now I hope I can get somewhere in my life. Plus I am defficent in Vitamin D, Low Ferritin, Adrenals w/ Blood draw was low,Thyroid Antibodies is kinda high, . So I am on supplements now. Plus I have noticed the more T4 that is pumped into my body, the worst I feel. Ive tried all the meds, nada works for me. I have also tried time released compounding/ synthetic form. I EVEN BEEN ON CYTOMEL 50MCG for a month and still wasn't myself but from what I have been reading I was'nt on it long enough and went about it all wrong. So I have learned and experimented with this condition. I just wanted to voice my opinion or my experience. I have had a rough road and life has been challenging. Thanks for listening or viewing my statement. Im open to any suggestions.

  10. Lisa August 21, 2012 10:29 pm

    Hi Lizzy,I was hoping you could help. I never even heard of other thyroid medication other than synthroid and levothyroxine. I am currently taking 130mcg. I am desperately trying to lose weight and have been only eating about 900 calories a day for the past month, and exercising an hour a day. Ive only lost about 4 pounds so far 🙁 Should I try a different thyroid medication? if so what are the different ones out there that are better in your opinion?

  11. Lizzy August 29, 2012 2:03 am

    Yes! Try desiccated thyroid medicine like Armor, Naturthroid, or the Compound I have specially made at Collier's Drug in Arkansas. If you search my site you will find info on the compound. xoxo! Lizzy

  12. Cat May 22, 2013 4:12 pm

    Hi! I finally convinced my doctor to let me try natural desiccated thyroid, I live in Canada so I assume its EFRA…. now I just read here that "it sucks". I've only been taking it for a week but now I'm not sure what to do….. according to my doctor this is the only natural one avaliable in Canada! Any advice??Also, what is the best way to transition between meds?

  13. Christy May 23, 2013 3:28 pm

    Does your pharmacists ship? I am hopefully seeing a renowned specialist but it could take 2 months to get an appt. I'm holding onto hope that someone or something can help.

  14. Lizzy June 29, 2013 1:41 am

    Hi Christy, I'm so sorry for the slow reply. I tend to get my messages faster on the Facebook group page so please feel free to write me there too. Collier's Drug does ship their compound. So definitely yes. But also, recently I decided to try an experiment with a new NDT called "NP Thyroid" by the Pharmaceutical company "Acella". I am still experimenting before posting formal results. But so far I am liking it a lot. It's available by prescription at most pharmacies. Except at this moment they are backordered for a week or two. So that might be an option worth trying. NP Thyroid is like the old Armour, and its very affordable ($11/prescription without needing insurance). I hope that helps! xoxoxo! Lizzy

  15. Sarah October 21, 2013 10:14 pm

    Just found your blog today. I wanted to ask how you are doing on NP Thyroid? I'm on Nature-Throid and certainly noticed improvement but there's still a lot of symptoms that need resolved.

Post a Comment

  • Shop

    Hypothyroid and Adrenal Fatigue Worksheet

    Could you have Hypothyroidism, Adrenal Fatigue, or both and not know it?
    Instant digital download. This worksheet is organized in a simple, easy-to-follow format which includes the following beneficial resources:
    • Hypothyroid symptom checklist
    • Adrenal Fatigue symptom checklist
    • Simple chart for tracking body temperature
    • Lab work record chart for tracking results
    • Treatment options to discuss with a doctor
    Satisfaction guaranteed or a full refund
    Price: $6.95 
  • Lugol's Solution of Iodine 5 Percent

    J.CROW'S Lugol's Solution of Iodine 5% by Miss Lizzy. Low Heavy Metal Verified. Made from USA Sourced Iodine. Best Seller!

    What is the benefit of using iodine?

    According to, the thyroid (located at the frontal base of the neck) is the key gland that furnishes energy to every cell in the body. Its function is dependent on a balance of nutrients and trace minerals. These include zinc, copper, manganese and especially iodine.

    Iodine is an essential nutrient needed for the production of the body's thyroid hormones and is therefore required for normal thyroid function. Thyroid hormones are responsible for our basal metabolic rate (BMR), which reflects the body's use of energy. In addition, they are beneficial for:

    • Normal growth and development
    • Protein synthesis
    • Cholesterol synthesis
    • Carbohydrate absorption
    • Energy metabolism
    • Nerve and bone formation
    • Reproduction
    • The condition of the skin, hair, nails and teeth
    • Speech and mental state
    • Cold hands and feet

    Lugol's Solution of Iodine 5 Percent - Buy Now!


    To contact me, please follow me on Facebook (Click "Like" below) and then either post on the wall or send a direct private message.

    For product questions:
    Miss Lizzy Thyroid for Life
    PO Box 464
    West Simsbury CT 06092
  • Follow Me on Facebook

  • Newsletter Sign Up

Copyright © 2012-2013 Miss Lizzy. Designed by